Peter Millar Reviews
Peter Millar has an overall rating of 4.0 based on 53 reviews. Customer feedback on Peter Millar is mixed: Peter Millar reviewers highlight positive aspects like high-quality materials, stylish designs, excellent customer service, comfortable fit, which strongly appeal to fashion-conscious individuals, affluent customers, golf and outdoor enthusiasts. However, Peter Millar is often criticized for its higher price point, limited size options, occasional shipping delays, inconsistent sizing.
53 reviews
5 Stars
16
4 Stars
7
3 Stars
4
2 Stars
3
1 Star
2
How would you rate Peter Millar?
All Peter Millar Reviews (53)
EdwinCherry
May 29, 2026
"I ordered a couple of shirts from..."
I ordered a couple of shirts from Peter Millar, and the colors were exactly what I was hoping for. I was a little unsure if one of them might look too bright in person, but it ended up matching the pictures on the site really well.
It definitely makes online shopping feel less like a guessing game when navy actually looks like navy. I’m happy with how they turned out, and I’d probably recommend giving them a try if accurate colors matter to you
It definitely makes online shopping feel less like a guessing game when navy actually looks like navy. I’m happy with how they turned out, and I’d probably recommend giving them a try if accurate colors matter to you
0
Reply
RobertaWaller_56
May 28, 2026
"Nice quality, but bit expensive"
I ordered a polo and pair of shorts from Peter Millar, and quality is really good. They fit me better than most brands I usually buy, which was nice surprise. Only thing is price is definitely on the high side, so I probably wouldn’t shop there all the time unless there’s sale or I know I’ll wear it a lot. Still feels worth it overall, just not exactly cheap
0
Reply
robertnicholson9511
May 16, 2026
"Felt Misled by the Lack of Support"
I reached out to Peter Millar customer service a few different times about my order, it felt like I was being ignored. I expected better communication based on the brand and the prices, but all I got was vague or no response and a lot of waiting around. It made me feel misled, like the customer support they imply just isn’t really there. Super frustrating experience, and I don’t see myself ordering again.
0
Reply
jacob-Scruggs
May 15, 2026
"I had a sizing mix-up with my order..."
I had a sizing mix-up with my order, but the support team were really quick about getting it sorted and sending out a replacement. No hassle at all, and I’m really happy with how it turned out.
0
Reply
william_Parker03
May 13, 2026
"Returning my shirt was really easy"
I ended up needing to send a shirt back, i was expecting it to be a hassle. But the return steps were really clear, and I got through everything quickly. It was a smooth experience from start to finish.
0
Reply
AndyPeterson
May 12, 2026
"My order came sooner than I expected. That..."
My order came sooner than I expected. That was a nice surprise. Tracking worked fine too. I just wish the packaging had been a little better
0
Reply
troy_Davis72
May 10, 2026
"Pretty much exactly as described"
The shirt was basically just what I expected. The size seemed right and the color matched the description, so overall I’m happy with it.
0
Reply
Kyle.paparo
May 08, 2026
"I really like the style of their..."
I really like the style of their shirts and polos. They’re simple and sharp without being too flashy. I spent about a few minutes browsing the site, and it was easy to get around. Everything felt well put together.
0
Reply
james1984
May 02, 2026
"Found way too much to like"
I went in just to browse, but there was so much good stuff that I felt a little trapped in the best way. The selection was great, and finding my size was actually really easy.
0
Reply
diannestone1514
May 02, 2026
"Still looks good after a bunch of washes"
I’ve washed these shirts a bunch now, and they’re still holding up really well. They don’t come out stretched, stiff, or weird, and they’ve been through the dryer too without losing the fit. i’m happy with them, but if the quality ever starts dropping, I’d probably look somewhere else.
0
Reply
TeresaHeine_26
April 29, 2026
"Shopping on the site was kind of a hassle"
The site looks nice, but every shopping site seems to make it harder than it needs to be to find your size or filter things properly. Pages were loading slowly for me too, which got annoying after a while. Checkout wasn’t the worst thing ever, but it didn’t feel very smooth either
0
Reply
jacqueline-Wilkerson
April 21, 2026
"I thought the size I needed was..."
I thought the size I needed was available when I ordered, but then it turned out it wasn’t. Maybe I missed something, but it definitely seemed like it was in stock at the time
0
Reply
Christine-rose
April 09, 2026
"Checkout was quick and easy"
I had a smooth time checking out on Peter Millar. The site was easy enough to click around, my cart updated like it was supposed to, and the payment went through without any random errors popping up, which is all I ask for these days. I was doing this while half-watching something on TV and trying to remember if I left laundry in the washer, so I appreciated that it didn’t make me think too hard. The order confirmation came through quickly too. Nothing fancy to report, just simple and easy
0
Reply
Nicholas.walsh
April 07, 2026
"Exchanges are such a hassle"
Well... trying to do an exchange was more frustrating than it should’ve been. It just didn’t feel easy or straightforward at all
0
Reply
rose.Middleton
March 29, 2026
"Sizing was pretty much spot on"
It fit true to size, honestly... the only thing I noticed was the sleeves were a little long, but not a huge deal.
0
Reply
hello_michael987
March 17, 2026
"Made it through the whole day looking decent"
I put this shirt on in the morning figuring it would be a wrinkled mess by the time I got home, but it actually held up really well. I wore it through work, running around a bit afterward, and by dinner it only had a few small creases. Nothing too noticeable, and better than I expected. Solid if you want something that still looks presentable after a full day.
0
Reply
hello_clifford795
March 05, 2026
"Found the return info fast. Super clear. No..."
Found the return info fast. Super clear. No digging around. No guessing. Just simple.
0
Reply
hello_janie700
March 01, 2026
"Nice shirts, but I expected a little more??"
I picked up a couple of Peter Millar performance polos, and overall they’re good. The fabric is lightweight and actually does a solid job wicking sweat when it’s hot out. The fit is nice too, relaxed without looking baggy or feeling too tight. That said, for the price, I was kind of expecting them to hold up better?? One of the shirts already started looking a little worn after just a few washes, which was disappointing. They’re still comfortable and totally wearable, just not quite as impressive as I thought they’d be. Shipping was fine, no issues there.
0
Reply
Tina.hardesty
February 23, 2026
"Really happy with these after a few weeks"
I bought two polos from Peter Millar a few weeks ago, and so far I’m really impressed. When they first arrived, the fabric felt soft and high quality without feeling thin or flimsy. I’ve washed them a couple of times since then, and they’ve held up really well. The fit was better than I expected too, which was a nice surprise. Overall, I’m happy with the purchase...
0
Reply
hello_robert925
February 19, 2026
"Exactly What I Picked"
I’m really thankful my order came exactly as I chose it. The sizes and colors were all correct, and there weren’t any missing items or mix-ups. Shipping took a little longer than I was hoping for, but overall I’m happy with the experience...
0
Reply
Have a question about Peter Millar?
Log in to ask your Peter Millar question!
Popular Brands
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
